1. What is Carbon Equivalent Calculator?

Definition: This calculator determines the carbon equivalent (CE) or critical metal parameter (Pcm) of steel based on the weight percentages of alloying elements, aiding in assessing the steel's weldability.

Purpose: It is used in metallurgy and welding to predict the likelihood of hydrogen-induced cold cracking, helping engineers and welders decide on preheating requirements and welding techniques.

2. How Does the Calculator Work?

The calculator uses the following equations:

• $\text{CE (IIW)}=C+\frac{Mn}{6}+\frac{Cu+Ni}{15}+\frac{Cr+Mo+V}{5}$
• $\text{CE (AWS)}=C+\frac{Mn+Si}{6}+\frac{Cr+Mo+V}{5}+\frac{Cu+Ni}{15}$
• $\text{Pcm (JWES)}=C+\frac{Si}{30}+\frac{Mn+Cu+Cr}{20}+\frac{Ni}{60}+\frac{Mo}{15}+\frac{V}{10}+5B$
• $\text{CE (JWES)}=C+\frac{Si}{24}+\frac{Mn}{6}+\frac{Ni}{40}+\frac{Cr}{5}+\frac{Mo}{4}+\frac{V}{14}$

Where:

• $C$: Carbon percentage (%);
• $Mn$: Manganese percentage (%);
• $Si$: Silicon percentage (%);
• $Cu$: Copper percentage (%);
• $Ni$: Nickel percentage (%);
• $Cr$: Chromium percentage (%);
• $Mo$: Molybdenum percentage (%);
• $V$: Vanadium percentage (%);
• $B$: Boron percentage (%).

Steps:

• Select the formula type (IIW, AWS, JWES Pcm, or JWES CE).
• Enter the weight percentages of alloying elements ($C$, $Mn$, $Si$, $Cu$, $Ni$, $Cr$, $Mo$, $V$).
• If JWES Pcm is selected, enter the Boron percentage ($B$).
• Validate inputs: Ensure $C\le 2.14\mathrm{\%}$ and all percentages are non-negative.
• Calculate CE or Pcm using the selected formula.
• Assess weldability:
  • For CE formulas (IIW, AWS, JWES CE):
    • CE ≤ 0.40%: Very Good (No preheating).
    • 0.40% < CE ≤ 0.60%: Moderate (Preheating may be required).
    • CE > 0.60%: Poor (Preheating compulsory).
  • For Pcm (JWES Pcm):
    • Pcm ≤ 0.30%: Very Good (No preheating).
    • 0.30% < Pcm ≤ 0.50%: Moderate (Preheating may be required).
    • Pcm > 0.50%: Poor (Preheating compulsory).
• Display results: CE or Pcm value and weldability assessment.

3. Importance of Carbon Equivalent Calculation

Calculating carbon equivalent or Pcm is crucial for:

• Weldability Prediction: Determines the risk of cold cracking, guiding welding procedures.
• Material Selection: Helps choose steels with suitable properties for specific applications.
• Cost Efficiency: Avoids unnecessary preheating or overly conservative welding practices.

4. Using the Calculator

Example 1 (JWES Pcm Formula): Calculate Pcm for a steel alloy:

• Composition: $C=0.18\mathrm{\%}$, $Si=0.30\mathrm{\%}$, $Mn=1.0\mathrm{\%}$, $Cu=0.02\mathrm{\%}$, $Ni=0.01\mathrm{\%}$, $Cr=0.05\mathrm{\%}$, $Mo=0.01\mathrm{\%}$, $V=0.01\mathrm{\%}$, $B=0.0005\mathrm{\%}$;
• Formula: $\text{Pcm}=C+\frac{Si}{30}+\frac{Mn+Cu+Cr}{20}+\frac{Ni}{60}+\frac{Mo}{15}+\frac{V}{10}+5B$;
• Calculation: $\text{Pcm}=0.18+\frac{0.30}{30}+\frac{1.0+0.02+0.05}{20}+\frac{0.01}{60}+\frac{0.01}{15}+\frac{0.01}{10}+5\times 0.0005$;
• $\text{Pcm}=0.18+0.01+\frac{1.07}{20}+\frac{0.01}{60}+\frac{0.01}{15}+\frac{0.01}{10}+0.0025$;
• $\text{Pcm}=0.18+0.01+0.0535+0.0001667+0.0006667+0.001+0.0025\approx 0.2478$;
• Weldability: Pcm ≈ 0.2478% (Very Good, no preheating required);
• Result: Pcm = 0.2478%, Weldability: Very Good.

Example 2 (JWES CE Formula): Calculate CE for AISI 1018 steel:

• Composition: $C=0.20\mathrm{\%}$, $Si=0.25\mathrm{\%}$, $Mn=0.90\mathrm{\%}$, $Ni=0\mathrm{\%}$, $Cr=0\mathrm{\%}$, $Mo=0\mathrm{\%}$, $V=0\mathrm{\%}$;
• Formula: $\text{CE}=C+\frac{Si}{24}+\frac{Mn}{6}+\frac{Ni}{40}+\frac{Cr}{5}+\frac{Mo}{4}+\frac{V}{14}$;
• Calculation: $\text{CE}=0.20+\frac{0.25}{24}+\frac{0.90}{6}+\frac{0}{40}+\frac{0}{5}+\frac{0}{4}+\frac{0}{14}$;
• $\text{CE}=0.20+0.0104167+0.15+0\approx 0.3604$;
• Weldability: CE ≈ 0.3604% (Very Good, no preheating required);
• Result: CE = 0.3604%, Weldability: Very Good.

5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: What is the difference between Pcm and CE formulas?
A: Pcm (JWES) focuses on critical metal parameters for high-strength steels, including Boron, with lower thresholds for weldability. CE formulas (IIW, AWS, JWES CE) are more general and assess overall hardenability.

Q: Why are Boron percentages typically very small?
A: Boron is a potent hardenability agent; even small amounts (e.g., 0.0005%) significantly affect steel properties, which is why the Pcm formula multiplies it by 5.

Q: Can this calculator be used for all steel types?
A: It is designed for carbon and low-alloy steels. High-alloy or stainless steels may require different formulas not covered here.

Carbon Equivalent Calculator© - All Rights Reserved 2025